The Dark Is Rising

The Dark Is Ris­ing sequence is a set of 5 books1 writ­ten by Susan Cooper between 1965 and 1977. It is with­out ques­tion my favorite series of books from when I was younger and it is also now being made into a movie. More acu­rately, the sec­ond book in the series is being made into a movie. When I heard about this, I tracked down the trailer on the offi­cial web­site2. After watch­ing the trailer, my ini­tial reac­tion was dis­ap­point­ment. It appears the story has under­gone some sub­stan­tial rewrites. As an addi­tional bad choice by the pro­duc­ers, they’ve cast an Amer­i­can as Will Stan­ton2 and Ian McShane as Mer­ri­man Lyon. While I am an Amer­i­can myself; cast­ing an Amer­i­can as the lead in a pro­foundly British story is hugely inap­pro­pri­ate. I really wish the pro­duc­ers of the movie had taken a note from the Harry Pot­ter movies and lim­ited their cast­ing to the U.K. Also the rea­son I object to Ian McShane is I still think of him as Love­joy and I think I’ll have great dif­fi­cultly in tak­ing him seri­ously in this movie. On the bright side, they did cast Christo­pher Eccle­ston as the Rider and I have no doubt about his abil­ity to play that role.

So I am look­ing for­ward to see­ing this and hope­fully it won’t suck like the trailer.

1 Over Sea, Under Stone, The Dark is Ris­ing, Green­witch, The Grey King and Sil­ver on a Tree
2 I’d give you a direct link to the trailer, but they built their site entirely in flash so there’s no way for me to do so. Apple now has the trailer for The Dark is Ris­ing on their movie trail­ers page.
3 The main char­ac­ter of the book.

Similar Posts

  • Fantastic Four
    The next Marvel Comics movie, the Fantastic Four is due out 1 July 2005 and their official website w ...
  • Pukka’s Links of the Week
    From Pukka: Shining Movie Trailer [Editor] This is a "remake" of the original trailer. Only this ver ...
  • The Golden One
    I finished reading Ms. Peter's The Golden One last night and while I found the book slow to start of ...
  • The movie we should have watched last weekend is…
    Shaun of the Dead Shaun isn't having the greatest of times. The staff at the TV store he works in do ...
  • Review: Wheel of Time
    The Wheel of Time is a series of books by Robert Jordan. The series started out very promisingl, int ...

About Mark McKibben

Mark works as a [REDACTED] for [REDACTED], currently residing in Iowa. CoffeeBear.net is a place for him to blather on about whatever strikes his fancy. He currently spends his "free" time working on a photography project, playing with his cat and attempting to keep his wife happy (not necessarily in that order).

6 Comments

  1. lulu says:
    July 31st, 2007 at 8:41 am

    I agree about the stu­pid­ity of cast­ing Amer­i­cans in such an Eng­lish story. But I wanted to remind you that McShane’s a great char­ac­ter actor and Love­joy was just one role in his 45 year career; give the guy a chance. I’m guess­ing you never watched Dead­wood or Sexy Beast?

  2. Mark says:
    July 31st, 2007 at 5:09 pm

    Nope. I’ve heard of Dead­wood, but Sexy Beast is entirely unfami­lar to me. I just took a look over Mr. McShane’s IMDB pro­file and it appears exten­sive. So it’s entirely pos­si­ble he’ll do a fine job but my only expe­ri­ence with his work is Lovejoy.

  3. Shawn Pow­ers says:
    August 6th, 2007 at 9:22 pm

    Hey Mark,

    I’m embar­rassed to admit I’d never heard of Susan Cooper, or the book series. Thanks for the tip to an excit­ing way for me to spend next week. :) (We’re going camp­ing, and I’ve been try­ing to fig­ure out what books to bring — hope­fully I can get a cou­ple of these in time.)

    I laughed in your “About” page, because I too have peo­ple think­ing I drink waaay more cof­fee than I actu­ally do. That’s not to say I don’t drink a lot more than I prob­a­bly should…

    –Shawn

  4. Mark says:
    August 6th, 2007 at 10:09 pm

    Well to be fair, the books are fairly old and I don’t believe they ever had much impact on the Amer­i­can public.

  5. Heather says:
    September 18th, 2007 at 12:18 am

    I had the same reac­tion — ini­tial dis­ap­point­ment at see­ing the story so changed, and espe­cially at the seem­ing mis-casting of the two main characters.

    Mer­ri­man always seemed more like a Max von Sydow or even Jack Palance (if he could do British…) — very old-looking, and yet still very pow­er­ful. Ian McShane seems too young — but he is a great actor, so I’m will­ing to keep an open mind.

    I will def­i­nitely see this movie, and just HOPE that the dra­matic rewrites and Amer­i­can Will add up to an inter­est­ing new story. At least the fact that it seems so dif­fer­ent makes me a lit­tle less ner­vous about it “ruin­ing” the story for me. I always pre­fer my own imag­in­ings of what the var­i­ous char­ac­ters in a favorite book look and sound like.

  6. Mark says:
    September 19th, 2007 at 9:44 am

    I’m not famil­iar with Max von Sydow but I do think you’re right about Jack Palance. He’s got the right look to him and if he could pull off being British… He’d be about perfect.

Leave a Reply

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.